What is data sovereignty?

Aerial view of Water dam near to a black forest in Germany

What is data sovereignty?

Data sovereignty is an organization’s ability to retain authority over its data — including access, processing, security and location — throughout its entire lifecycle, as well as its ability to log and prove that control.

Practicing data sovereignty requires businesses to establish strong identity access controls, encryption and data services to protect it. Those practices, in turn, are the building blocks of data sovereignty, which is meant to help ensure access, secrets, keys, logs and audit evidence remain in compliance and under an organization’s control.

Data sovereignty is one of the pillars of digital sovereignty, an organization’s ability to retain and prove control and authority over its technology systems and ecosystems, data, operations and artificial intelligence (AI). Along with operational sovereignty, technology sovereignty, and AI sovereignty, data sovereignty supports a business’ efforts to retain autonomy over its entire technology stack.

Data sovereignty is a spectrum, not an absolute. Depending on the relevant regulations and business standards where data is stored, processed and deployed, it might need either especially stringent controls or minimal ones. For example, a hospital that retains both clinical records containing patients’ personally identifiable information (PII) and records that are de-identified for research purposes would need to practice tight access controls on the former that are not required for the latter.

Data sovereignty vs. data residency vs. data localization

Data sovereignty, residency and localization are all closely related terms. However, there are some key differences that organizations should understand in establishing their overall data sovereignty position.

  • Data sovereignty is the overall principle that data is under control and compliant with regard to factors such as where it is stored or processed, where it was collected and which entities control it.

  • Data residency is the physical or geographical location where data is stored or processed, especially when that location is different from where it was created.

  • Data localization refers to requirements that specified data be stored, processed or otherwise handled within a particular jurisdiction.

Data location still matters to the concept of data sovereignty, but newer frameworks assert that the location of data, as in the case of where a data center is placed, is insufficient without expanding to include broader questions of control: that is, the ability to demonstrate independent authority enabling enforceable compliance over data.

How is data sovereignty determined?

Data-sovereignty requirements are determined by laws in jurisdictions that are connected to the data and the entities that collect, store, process or control it.

These laws vary from territory to territory, but typically, when a country is said to have its own “sovereignty over” a piece of data, it means it holds jurisdiction and authority over how that data can be used and who can access it. However, often, data is subject to more than one country’s laws (see: data residency and data localization) and the governing, storage and processing of it becomes more complicated.

When data is collected in one jurisdiction and handled otherwise in one or more others, the organization using the data must satisfy the relevant laws in each situation.

For example, multinational organizations may need contractual safeguards and transfer mechanisms to satisfy laws that specifically regulate cross-border data transfers. Sector-specific laws may impose additional privacy and security obligations when covered health information is involved. Also, organizations storing and processing data in multiple regions or countries should be knowledgeable about any relevant data protection policies and laws, restrictions on cross-border transfers or other concerns required to maintain data privacy and integrity.

Legal jurisdiction may be determined by the service provider rather than by the server location. The US CLOUD Act of 2018 permits U.S. authorities to compel providers subject to U.S. jurisdiction to hand over data they control, even when the data resides in another country. The growing movement for indigenous data sovereignty advocates for the rights of indigenous peoples to govern data collection, ownership, and use of their data, regardless of overlapping sovereignties.

In the European Union, the Data Act supports switching and interoperability between data-processing services and establishes safeguards around unlawful third-country governmental access to non-personal data. Such legal conflicts explain why governments view data location as a national security concern instead of merely a privacy issue.

Other regulatory frameworks of particular concern for data sovereignty include:

  • The European Union’s General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR), which defines legally approved ways to transfer and process personal data, details how organizations must protect personal data at rest and in transit, and establishes rights over personal data collection, use and possession

  • The United States’ Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA), which governs the privacy and security of protected health data

  • The California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA), which regulates personal information and grants California residents rights concerning its collection, use, disclosure, sale and sharing

  • The Australian Privacy Principles, which govern the collection, use and disclosure of personal information, organizations’ data governance and accountability, the integrity and correction of personal information, and individual rights

Retaining data sovereignty while complying with local laws

Key concerns for organizations seeking to comply with local laws typically include:

  • cybersecurity
  • data security and privacy
  • protecting sensitive data from data breaches and malware
  • controlling which individuals, entities and applications can access data.

For example, the EU General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) requires organizations to appoint a Data Protection Officer (DPO) for certain practices including large-scale monitoring or large-scale processing of sensitive personal data, to advise the organization and monitor compliance.

Cloud storage poses a particular challenge for practicing data sovereignty: When data is stored and processed across multiple jurisdictions according to the business practices of a cloud provider, it can be challenging for an organization to maintain visibility over where data is located and whether it is in compliance. This requires strong scrutiny and consideration of providers to ensure they can uphold sovereignty requirements. 

What is AI Data Management?

Discover, Clean, & Secure Data with AI

Discover how AI Data Management tackles shadow data, poor data quality, and security risks, using AI-powered classification, natural language queries, and anomaly detection to unlock insights and streamline operations.

Data sovereignty as a component of digital sovereignty

Data sovereignty is one of four dimensions within a broader framework of digital sovereignty.

Digital sovereignty describes an organization’s ability to retain control and authority over its technology systems and ecosystems, data, operations and artificial intelligence (AI) — as well its ability to prove that control and authority when it matters. Digital sovereignty is a form of independence and autonomy.

Transparency, another important aspect of digital sovereignty, refers to an organization’s ability to audit its processes and outcomes. Transparency ensures that organizations can see into their most important operational workflows so they can see what is working and what needs to be changed.

In addition to data sovereignty, digital sovereignty includes:

  • Operational sovereignty
  • Technological sovereignty
  • AI sovereignty

Operational sovereignty

Operational sovereignty ensures that critical infrastructure associated with data-rich applications is always-on and accessible. It helps enterprises maintain transparency and control over their operational processes and spot inefficiencies.

With a sound approach to operational sovereignty, even if a particular region is affected by a disaster an enterprise can ensure their critical infrastructure is resilient. Many operational sovereignty approaches include a business continuity disaster recovery (BCDR) or disaster recovery as a service (DRaaS) plan. Operational sovereignty helps enterprises comply with local regulations governing the infrastructure needed to support cloud environments in a particular region.

Technological sovereignty

Technology sovereignty is the use of open, modular architecture meant to avoid vendor lock-in. Sometimes called software sovereignty or technology independence, it centers on the ability to run and move workloads across providers rather than being bound to one proprietary stack. Open standards and open-source software can be means towards the end of technology sovereignty, because they can often make a system both portable and transparent.

AI sovereignty

AI sovereignty, sometimes called sovereign AI, is control over where artificial intelligence and machine learning models run, as well as how inference—the actual work of a trained model producing outputs—is governed. As organizations embed AI workloads into core operations, sovereignty extends from where data is stored to how models are accessed at runtime, how their decisions are logged and how AI security is maintained. IBM’s research has found that 83% of CEOs say AI sovereignty is essential to their business strategy.

The four-step approach to enterprise data sovereignty

To get started implementing an effective approach to data sovereignty, organizations should take the following steps:

Familiarize yourself with relevant laws and regulations

Enterprises looking to develop on-premises or cloud-based data capabilities in more than one region or country should first educate themselves on the laws and regulations governing data sovereignty in those territories.

Cross-border data transfers pose a core challenge for data sovereignty because transferring data across borders makes it subject to multiple laws and regulatory requirements simultaneously. Organizations should manage international data flows so that storage, processing and transfers comply with applicable rules wherever the data is processed or stored.

Establish a communication channel with the relevant authorities

When appropriate based on applicable regulations or identified risk, organizations should contact the agencies in charge of enforcing data sovereignty laws in the countries or regions where an organization does business to communicate plans around data storage, processing and transfers. Maintaining audit logs is crucial to help ensure an organization is able to prove compliance when it matters.

Establish strong security practices

Organizations cannot ensure data sovereignty without strong cybersecurity practices. Strong identity and access controls, encryption and monitoring help to ensure control of data and compliance at all stages of the lifecycle.

Particular threats to sovereignty include conflicting jurisdictional requirements, which require organizations to either control workflows to avoid the overlapping requirements or avoid certain jurisdictions altogether, and third-party provider risk, where CSPs and other partners can introduce their own vulnerabilities. That makes evaluating providers’ cybersecurity, encryption, governance, auditing and compliance capabilities a key part of maintaining data sovereignty.

Partner with local experts

Compliance laws in many regions where cloud computing is popular can change quickly. It’s always a good idea to have someone in the country or region you’re storing and processing data who is an expert in the territory’s regulatory agreements. Organizations should verify whether a cloud service provider (CSP) is subject to relevant local laws, regulatory supervision, licensing requirements or sector-specific approvals, and then assess the provider’s contractual and technical commitments.

Key considerations for enterprises looking to establish data sovereignty

As citizens and regulatory bodies around the globe continue to raise data sovereignty concerns, sovereign cloud approaches are helping businesses ensure the integrity of their data no matter where it’s stored and processed.

In the coming years, how organizations gather, secure, store and control access to their data—especially if they are looking to tap new, data-rich technologies like AI and ML—will have enormous implications for growth and security. Data sovereignty is at the center of these concerns, so choosing a cloud provider that has a deep understanding of it will help businesses implement a strong sovereign cloud approach and achieve their digital transformation goals. Partners in regions and countries where enterprises seek to establish a cloud environment must have strategies to mitigate common risks like cyberattacks, natural disasters and downtime.

Finally, businesses looking to create a strong approach to data sovereignty and sovereign cloud must ensure that their cloud provider has a strong overall cloud strategy that aligns with the laws of the countries or regions they operate in.

Some important features enterprises should consider when considering CSPs and other partners include:

Data governance capabilities

A CSP’s approach to data governance shows that they have the right policies and procedures in place to successfully handle sensitive data and apply the necessary restrictions around it. They should also provide regular audits, audit logging and provable audit trails showing the guidelines they’ve put in place are being followed.

Service level agreements (SLAs)

When creating an SLA around data sovereignty in a sovereign cloud environment, the three most important areas the SLA should cover are control (cloud management), availability and performance.

Compliance

CSP’s and other partners helping enterprises comply with data sovereignty requirements should have a high level of expertise in all data laws in the regions where they operate. Ideally, enterprises and their CSPs should share responsibility for staying up to date with new regulations and developing strategies to deal with them.

Data encryption

It’s critical that CSPs in the sovereign cloud space have robust data encryption capabilities like cryptographic keys to ensure that they can keep sensitive data safe and accessible. Encryption algorithms use cryptographic keys to transform readable data into ciphertext that can be decrypted only with the corresponding key. Strong encryption and key control can help protect against unauthorized access, but organizations must also practice access control including the management of privileged access, key custody, backups, metadata and protection while data is being processed.

Resiliency

A strong approach to data sovereignty and sovereign cloud environments should include strong resiliency features. Enterprises should only consider CSPs with proven track records of helping clients with resiliency and recovery efforts in relevant countries or regions. When it comes to a sovereign cloud environment, all cloud deployments should have built-in recovery and fail-over capabilities tailored to each specific regulatory compliance area where data is being stored.

Authors

Derek Robertson

Staff Writer

IBM Think

Mesh Flinders

Staff Writer

IBM Think

Ian Smalley

Staff Editor

IBM Think

Related solutions
IBM Sovereign Core

Purpose-built sovereign software that empowers enterprises, governments and service providers to create, deploy and manage secure, AI-ready environments.

Explore IBM Sovereign Core
Digital sovereignty solutions
Stay ahead of evolving regulations. IBM helps organizations meet compliance requirements, govern AI responsibly and maintain visibility across data, applications and infrastructure.
Explore digital sovereignty solutions
Cloud strategy consulting 
Build a cloud strategy that balances innovation with control. IBM helps organizations design hybrid cloud environments that support data sovereignty, security, compliance and business agility. 
Explore cloud strategy consulting
Take the next step

Discover how IBM Sovereign Core empowers enterprises, governments and service providers with purpose-built sovereign software to create, deploy and manage AI-ready environments, while maintaining full autonomy over data, infrastructure and technology.

  1. Discover IBM Sovereign Core
  2. Explore digital sovereignty solutions