HD45705: GSD \ ROUGH STOCK \ ROUGH STOCK POSITIONED

APAR status

• Closed as unreproducible in next release.

Error description

• GSD \ ROUGH STOCK \ ROUGH STOCK
  POSITIONED INCORRECTLY WHEN BASED ON CG
  AXIS
  .
  SCENARIO:
  1. Open a CATPart containing a PartBody with a
  solid goemetry (the problem is easier to see if the
  part is skewed from the primary planes).
  2. Switch to GSD workbench.
  3. Make sure the SURFACE MACHINING TOOLS
  toolbar is available, to access the ROUGH STOCK
  tool.
  4. Click the ROUGH STOCK tool.
  5. Select the part body (note the black lines around
  the part).
  6. Click OK to create the rough stock envelope.
  7. Note the correct position of the rough stock
  around the part.
  8. Hide the geometric set called Rough Stock.
  9. Click the MEASURE INERTIA tool.
  10. Click the part body (note the white lines around
  the part).
  11. Click CREATE GEOMETRY and click AXIS
  SYSTEM and OK (note the new axis created in the
  center of the part).
  Repeat the rough stock creation.
  12. Click the ROUGH STOCK tool.
  13. Select the part body again.
  14. In the panel, click on the AXIS box and select
  the center of gravity axis (from step 11).
  15. Note the black lines around the part (probably
  different from step 5).
  16. Click OK to create the rough stock based on
  the new axis.
  .
  OBSERVATION:
  This second rough stock envelop is built shifted
  away from the part, and does not match the
  preview lines that were shown in step 15.
  .
  EXPECTED RESULT:
  This second rough stock envelop should not be built
  shifted away from the part, and should match the
  preview lines that were shown in step 15.
  .
  

Local fix

Problem summary

• GSD \ ROUGH STOCK \ ROUGH STOCK POSITIONED
  INCORRECTLY WHEN BASED ON CG AXIS
  GSD \ ROUGH STOCK \ ROUGH STOCK
  POSITIONED INCORRECTLY WHEN BASED ON CG
  AXIS
  .
  SCENARIO:
  1. Open a CATPart containing a PartBody with a
  solid goemetry (the problem is easier to see if the
  part is skewed from the primary planes).
  2. Switch to GSD workbench.
  3. Make sure the SURFACE MACHINING TOOLS
  toolbar is available, to access the ROUGH STOCK
  tool.
  4. Click the ROUGH STOCK tool.
  5. Select the part body (note the black lines around
  the part).
  6. Click OK to create the rough stock envelope.
  7. Note the correct position of the rough stock
  around the part.
  8. Hide the geometric set called Rough Stock.
  9. Click the MEASURE INERTIA tool.
  10. Click the part body (note the white lines around
  the part).
  11. Click CREATE GEOMETRY and click AXIS
  SYSTEM and OK (note the new axis created in the
  center of the part).
  Repeat the rough stock creation.
  12. Click the ROUGH STOCK tool.
  13. Select the part body again.
  14. In the panel, click on the AXIS box and select
  the center of gravity axis (from step 11).
  15. Note the black lines around the part (probably
  different from step 5).
  16. Click OK to create the rough stock based on
  the new axis.
  .
  OBSERVATION:
  This second rough stock envelop is built shifted
  away from the part, and does not match the
  preview lines that were shown in step 15.
  .
  EXPECTED RESULT:
  This second rough stock envelop should not be built
  shifted away from the part, and should match the
  preview lines that were shown in step 15.
  .
  

Problem conclusion

Temporary fix

Comments

• THE PROBLEM WAS SUBMITTED ON :
  CATIA VERSION 5 RELEASE 15.
  THIS PROBLEM IS NOT REPRODUCIBLE ON :
  CATIA VERSION 5 RELEASE 18 GA level
  .
  This second rough stock envelop is not built
  shifted away from the part, and is matching
  the preview lines that were shown in step 15.
  Note that this problem is also not
  reproducible on R17SP01 level.
  .
  

APAR Information

• APAR is sysrouted FROM one or more of the following:

• APAR is sysrouted TO one or more of the following:

Fix information

• Fixed component name

  CATIA V5 NT>XP

• Fixed component ID

  569151000

Applicable component levels

• R517 PSN

     UP